Let me start by this disclaimer: Under no circumstance do I assume that Australia (or most nations for that matter) can ever match the US when it comes to investing in new ventures. However, the US provides a glowing example of how things can be done, so one would hope learnings can be transferred elsewhere. However, there have been a lot of articles lately in Australian press highlighting some of the problems facing entrepreneurship in Australia when it comes to raising capital. I have certainly heard claims that improvements are happening – often referring to how companies like Pollenizer and Blue Chili lead the way to help entrepreneurs get to the next stage by providing them with critical services to grow. However, the capital sector is far lagging and one has to wonder how this up-hill battle will pan out.
Some recent reports perhaps highlight the issue clearer than anything I have seen before. VC investments in Australia dropped 24% in 2011 according to the Australian Venture Capital Association Yearbook . However, this is not the main number that stands out: Out of the total investments made, only 8% were made as seed capital – with a total of only $4.24m, which sadly represented a 128% increase YoY (meaning the base is pretty dismal):
I modified the data from the AVC to exclude buyouts, refinancing and replacing bank debt to come up with these %s. Let’s contrast this with a report from CB Insight from Q2 in the US:
This shows that in the US, the largest amount of deals are focused on the seed stage (The chart shows the internet sector. For all sectors, seed represented 22%). Contrasting this with the Australian number, it is clear that Aussie investors prefer not to invest in ideas and people, rather prefer to wait until revenues and products are proven, thereby taking less risk. What is the problem with this? Seed companies are the start of the funnel. In order to have enough quality deals in later stage, you need a healthy pipeline of seed companies – and availability of capital is the key to make this happen.
Is there hope? Well, there are organizations starting to attack this from the ground up, especially in terms of breeding better entrepreneurs. There are also some glimmer of hope with new funds being raised and new professional VCs being established. Whether that will help change the investor environment’s attitude towards risk remains to be seen – but hey, you have to start somewhere.